Your Go to ‘Best Black Hair Dye’ List for 2020 (Comparison Table and Full Reviews)

Spread the love

Contents

​Are you looking for a little change in your life but not one that's too drastic? How about styling a new hair color? The perfect solution for those wanting a change or wanting a quick solution with which you can use as graying coverage may be trying a new black hair dye. Well, you've come to the right place. We've compiled a list of the best black hair dyes on the market so you don't have to spend the extra cash to get it done at the hair salon, along with the pros and cons you may find with each dye. If you're looking for blonde hair dyes or red hair dyes instead, don't worry, we'll touch on that in another article.  ​For now, we're going to focus on the popular black hair color choice!

Coloring your hair black can be a safe and easy process if you know how to go about it. However, before you attempt dying your natural hair color, we recommend consulting with a professional hairstylist first to see if they can offer up any tips on how to maintain black as your new permanent hair color, and how to keep your hair as healthy as possible as even the best black hair dye can cause some issues. A professionally-trained colorist will be able to guide you better when it comes to choosing the best black dyes around, including the differences between popular brands like Clairol Nice N Easy, Clairol Natural Instincts, Garnier Nutrisse, Revlon, L'Oreal, and many more.

An important reminder: you should avoid hair dyes that contain harmful substances like alcohol and ammonia. Products with these chemicals can produce the results that you want unless however, you wanted blue and purple tones!

The Top 10​ Black Hair Dye

Product name Rating Price
Bigen EZ Color Hair Color for Men - Jet Black Kit Bigen EZ Color Hair Color for Men - Jet Black Kit --
Clairol Natural Instincts for Men Hair Color, Brown Black (M17) Clairol Natural Instincts for Men Hair Color, Brown Black (M17) --
Clairol Natural Instincts Hair Color For Men M19 Black 1 Kit (Pack of 3) - PACKAGING MAY VARY Clairol Natural Instincts Hair Color For Men M19 Black 1 Kit (Pack of 3) - PACKAGING MAY VARY $17.64
Clairol Nice 'n Easy Hair Color 122, 2 Natural Black 1 Kit (Pack of 3) Clairol Nice 'n Easy Hair Color 122, 2 Natural Black 1 Kit (Pack of 3) --
Cover Your Gray For Men Black Cover Your Gray For Men Black $4.56
Garnier Nutrisse Nourishing Hair Color Creme, 20 Soft Black (Black Tea)  (Packaging May Vary) Garnier Nutrisse Nourishing Hair Color Creme, 20 Soft Black (Black Tea) (Packaging May Vary) $6.99
Just 5 Women's Hair Color, Rich Black Just 5 Women's Hair Color, Rich Black $9.49
L'Oreal Excellence Creme Permanent Hair Color, Natural Black #3, 1.74 oz L'Oreal Excellence Creme Permanent Hair Color, Natural Black #3, 1.74 oz $6.98
Revlon Colorsilk Beautiful Color Hair Color, Soft Black Revlon Colorsilk Beautiful Color Hair Color, Soft Black --
SoftSheen-Carson Dark & Natural 5 Minute Shampoo-In Haircolor, Natural Black SoftSheen-Carson Dark & Natural 5 Minute Shampoo-In Haircolor, Natural Black $5.35

​Products

Clairol Nice 'n Easy Hair Color

Garnier Nutrisse Color Crème

L'Oréal Paris Excellence Créme Hair Color

Just For Men Men's Hair Color

Clairol Natural Instincts Hair Color For Men

Bigen EZ Hair Color for Men - Jet Black

SoftSheen-Carson Shampoo-In Haircolor

Revlon Colorsilk Beautiful Color

Just 5 Women's Hair Color

​Cover Your Gray Black For Men

​Our Black Hair Dye Reviews!

Clairol Nice 'n Easy Hair Color

​The Clairol Nice N Easy hair dye for women can handle any gray coverage needs and leave you with black hair that’s silky, shiny, and beautiful. This particular product uses three complementary lowlights and highlights from the impressive ColorBlend technology. With this hair dye, you will see rich tones through your strands. As a result, you can enjoy a natural-looking color which will easily last for up to eight weeks before requiring a touchup.

Our Average Review:

4.5 Out Of 5 Stars

​This product is anti-flat and provides a much-needed dimension to your hair. It makes your hair color look livelier than ever before. The exclusive ColorBlend technology formula provides built-in highlights and tones. This ensures the color isn’t flat or "matte" in appearance.

​Moreover, the dye comes with Color Seal conditioning gloss. This seals the intense shine and beautiful black colors you've been waiting and hoping for. Just one simple step and twenty-five minutes later, you will have glossy, black hair!

Pros

  • ​It is a beautiful black hair color, perfect for those wanting a new permanent hair color
  • ​Keeps your hair healthy, shiny, and soft just like natural hair
  • ​It is very gentle
  • ​Doesn’t fade too quickly

Cons

  • ​The strong smell may bother some people

Garnier Nutrisse Color Crème

​This Garnier Nutrisse black hair color for women provides you with a radiant and rich, ravenous look. It also keeps the hair looking silkier and shinier than ever before. This product comes contains grapeseed oil which nourishes the hair while it turns black. The after-color conditioner contains shea, olive, and avocado oils, also great for nourishing the hair. The oils lock the moisture in and protect your hair from drying out.

Our Average Review:

4.5 Out Of 5 Stars

​This black hair dye provides complete gray coverage and is very easy to use. It also doesn’t drip, and it smells great! Nutrisse penetrates deeply into your hair and nourishes and conditions every strand. As a result, the hair takes on the color better and retains it for longer for less frequent touchups! Consequently, you end up with silky soft hair that’s simply radiating.

Pros

  • ​It keeps your hair healthy
  • ​It doesn’t dry out your hair
  • ​Very simple to apply
  • ​It doesn’t smell as bad as other dyes do
  • ​The resulting black color is very beautiful and natural-looking

Cons

  • ​Some people might have to apply more than a couple of coats for full gray coverage

L'Oréal Paris Excellence Créme Hair Color

​This excellence crème by L’Oreal comes with a triple protection system. This system replenishes and seals moisture in your hair so you can enjoy color-lock protection for up to eight weeks.

Our Average Review:

4.5 Out Of 5 Stars

​After using this product, you will sport a new radiant and rich-in-color hairstyle. The triple protection system contains collagen, pro-keratin complex, and ceramide. These ingredients care for the hair before coloring, as well as after the process too.

​This pre-color treatment also contains ceramide. This helps to protect the treated ends from a buildup of color. It will also give you complete gray coverage and doesn’t even spare the most stubborn gray hairs!

Pros

  • Application is very easy
  • ​It gives you a completely natural-looking hair color
  • ​Available at a great price at most drug stores near you
  • ​It has a non-drip formula
  • ​Hair feels well-conditioned and soft afterward

Cons

  • ​The strong smell may bother some people

Just For Men Men's Hair Color

​Don't worry men, we didn't forget about you! This shampoo-like formula from Just For Men aims to provide a gray-free natural hair look. It covers all of the gray hair effectively and also preserves the variation of your natural hair color. The application only takes approximately five minutes, and the result lasts for up to eight weeks.

Our Average Review:

4.5 Out Of 5 Stars

​This hair color contains chamomile, vitamin E, and aloe - three great, all-natural ingredients so your hair looks thicker and healthier! Since the formula is ammonia-free, no damage is done to the hair strands. This hair color conditions every strand of hair and makes it easier to manage. Furthermore, this product contains a non-drip formula that ensures easy, lather-in application.

Pros

  • ​Mixing and application are very easy
  • ​It covers the gray hair strands quite well
  • ​It gives a very natural-look appearance
  • ​Has a non-drip formula
  • ​Comes at an affordable price in most drug stores near you

Cons

  • ​The gloves accompanying this hair dye are not of the best quality so you may need to invest in better ones

Clairol Natural Instincts Hair Color For Men

​This black hair color product for men is all about covering gray hair efficiently. In just ten minutes, you can enjoy healthy-looking black hair that you've always dreamt of having. This black hair dye feels and looks completely natural once you’re done applying it. Also, the gray coverage can last through 28 shampoo routines.

Our Average Review:

4.0 Out Of 5 Stars

​The Clairol Natural Instincts line carries some of the best black hair dyes since they contain vitamin E, aloe, and protein. Their recipe is also free from ammonia, thus ensuring that your hair stays away from any sort of chemical-induced damage. The formula for this reliable product has been crafted uniquely to condition and protect your hair while also providing you with the permanent hair color you desire.

Pros

  • ​The color lasts very long compared to many other dyes
  • ​It covers up all gray hair strands effectively, including those stubborn gray hairs
  • ​The ingredients are all-natural and healthy for your hair

Cons

  • ​The application process can take a bit longer than others
  • ​The gloves that come with the dye can feel a bit flimsy

Bigen EZ Hair Color for Men - Jet Black

​Dreaming of getting your jet black permanent hair color back? Using this hair dye is easy and doesn’t damage hair. The formula locks the moisture in and nourishes the hair as well as giving it it's color back, so say goodbye to those pesky grays! It can be used for multiple applications. This black hair color is quite beautiful and natural-looking.

Our Average Review:

4.0 Out Of 5 Stars

​This dye has an easy comb-in application. It doesn’t leave any stains on your skin either. Also, the thick, cream-like consistency of this product makes it very easy to apply. The formula makes hair smoother and healthier with every application.

Pros

  • There is no staining
  • ​The application process is absolutely mess-free
  • It has a non-drip formula
  • It is easy to use
  • ​Brings back your permanent black hair

Cons

  • ​It only lasts for a couple of weeks before re-application is required

SoftSheen-Carson Shampoo-In Haircolor

​This five-minute conditioning hair dye was specifically designed for men with graying hair. The rich and deep black hair color offers reliable gray blending coverage. Plus, it offers a completely natural-looking appearance after the application process. Gray hair coverage can last for up to six weeks.

Our Average Review:

4.0 Out Of 5 Stars

​While providing a handsome black color, the product also conditions the hair and softens it. The honey and Aloe Vera fortifies and moisturizes the hair and the formula is completely ammonia-free. This formula locks in your newly black hair color and leaves it looking and feeling healthy, manageable, and soft.

Pros

  • It doesn’t leave any stains
  • The process takes less than ten minutes
  • It gives the hair a very natural look
  • ​It's ammonia-free

Cons

  • ​The strong smell may bother some people

Revlon Colorsilk Beautiful Color

​This is a silky, radiant and long-lasting coloring formula for all types of hair. It is sure to leave your hair in a better condition than before. With this product, you can enjoy a natural-looking black hair color, from the tips down to the roots.

Our Average Review:

4.0 Out Of 5 Stars

​This dye has an ammonia-free, gentle formula that penetrates each strand. The after-color conditioner, which contains silk proteins, nourishes every hair strand for a healthier, shinier, and silkier result. It also provides 100% gray coverage.

Pros

  • ​It is affordable
  • ​It does not fade out as quickly as other black hair dyes
  • ​Leaves the hair looking shiny and feeling soft
  • ​It covers gray hair quite well

Cons

  • It doesn’t work well on synthetic hair

Just 5 Women's Hair Color

​With this ammonia-free hair dye, you can get a natural and shiny black color to feel good about. While also coloring your hair, this dye revitalizes each strand too. The super-rich conditioning formula is all about revitalizing and protecting your hair while providing volume and an additional shine to your locks.

Our Average Review:

4.0 Out Of 5 Stars

​This dye is very gentle on the hair and doesn’t fade out after shampooing. It will take you just five minutes to apply and the single-application process will last for up to six weeks.

Pros

  • ​It's easy to apply
  • No discoloration or stains
  • ​It easily lasts for six weeks
  • ​Provides efficient gray hair coverage

Cons

  • ​The strong smell may bother some people

Cover Your Gray Black For Men

​Coming to the end of our​ "Best Black Hair Dye" list. If you are looking for a temporary touch-up of black for your permanent hair color, then this is the perfect product for you. Take note that you don’t need to wash the serum after the application process.

Our Average Review:

4.0 Out Of 5 Stars

​It covers up all your gray hair in just a matter of minutes. It also blends pretty well with your existing permanent hair color. It's great for all kinds of hair types, including your facial hair! It doesn’t "matte" your hair or dry it out.

Pros

  • Easy to blend and use
  • ​A convenient and quick way to cover any gray hairs making an appearance

Cons

  • ​The color can come off easily compared to other dyes
  • ​Doesn't last as long as others

​Stuck Deciding On Black Hair Dyes?

​There are many different kinds of black hair dyes for men and women to choose from. First and foremost, you need to ensure that the formula of any of the black hair dyes are suitable for your hair, especially if you're hoping for a new permanent hair color. You should also ensure they're ammonia-free as to not damage your hair. So, while purchasing black hair dyes, read the chemical composition and ingredient list very carefully. Remember, you don’t want to buy something that irritates or stains your skin either.

Making the right decision is crucial when buying the best black hair dye. Think about the hair color and hair type you already have before choosing and consult a specialist about it. They're always more than happy to help you and provide their honest opinion about their favorite black hair dye brands, like L'Oreal, Clairol, Revlon, etc.

​Black Hair Dye Buying Guide

Lady with Black Hair Dye

​The main features you must look for when buying a hair dye include the following:

​Gray Coverage

​The hair color you chose should provide excellent gray hair coverage. In fact, the best hair dyes can even hide the most resistant and stubborn of gray hair.
Easy Application

​Easy Application

​If your chosen hair dye has a drippy formula, then the process will become difficult and messy. Get a hair dye that comes with helpful tools such as strong gloves and applicator nozzles to make things easier for you.
Dye Texture

​Dye Texture

​Try to purchase hair dyes that have a "creamy" texture. Dyes that have a foam or cream formula are thick and don’t drip a lot. This makes the clean-up process much easier too!

​Say No To Chemicals

​The dye you choose should have a non-irritating and non-damaging formula. It shouldn’t inflame the skin or fry and dry your permanent hair color. There are some dyes that leave hair shinier and healthier than before by adding all-natural ingredients like Aloe Vera, shea, grapeseed and avocado oils, etc.

How To Apply Black Hair Dye

how to apply black hair dye

​Before starting the application process, place a towel around your head. This will avoid the dripping of color onto your clothes.

Use gloves so that the color isn’t transferred to your hands. Also, apply oil or Vaseline around the hairline so that the color doesn’t spread.

Start applying the hair dye from the hairline on your forehead. Take a few strands of hair and then apply the dye on this portion. Keep doing this until you cover all the hair up to your neck.

After waiting for the time mentioned on the hair dye box, apply the remaining mixture on the hair. Pull the dye to the tips using a wide-tooth comb. This is to ensure an even distribution. Make sure that you leave the color on the tips for a maximum of five minutes.

Once the waiting period is over, rinse the hair thoroughly using tepid water. Continue washing the hair until the water runs completely clear. You must ensure that color is removed completely so there is no product build-up.

​Tips To Retain The Best Black Hair Dye For Longer Periods

​Hair dyes make hair more porous. Consequently, hair releases and absorbs moisture easily and when hair gets wet, color molecules are lost.

With just a little extra care, you can make sure that your black dyed hair stays vibrant and shiny for a longer period of time.

Try following these tips:

Shampoo less frequently

​If you want to make sure that your color isn’t washed away too soon, just wash your hair less often. To retain natural oils that condition your dyed hair, shampoo only up to three times in a week. Don’t wash your hair every other day. As a result, the color will last longer, and your hair will stay healthy too.

​Use The Proper Shampoo

​On the in-between days, use a dry, color-safe shampoo on your black dyed hair. If you want to keep the hair looking fresh, you can flip the hair and use a dry shampoo. Make sure that the shampoo is sprayed at the roots so that the oil can soak up.

​Keep The Hair Dry

​On the days you won’t be shampooing, make sure your hair stays dry. While taking a shower, use a shower cap. If your hair gets wet on the off days as well, the color can start to fade quickly. You could also keep the hair in a ponytail or a loose bun to keep it from getting wet.

(Last Updated On: May 1, 2020)

Leave a Comment